How the Cultivation of Wild Plants in Botanic Gardens can Change their Genetic and Phenotypic Status and What This Means for their Conservation Value

  • Andreas Ensslin Botanical Garden of the University of Bern
  • Sandrine Godefroid Botanic Garden Meise, employed by the Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles.

Abstract

The discipline of horticulture, growing and propagating plants under artificial conditions, has a centuries-long tradition and has developed into a vital industry of breeding, propagating and trading ornamental and wild plants around the globe. Botanic gardens have always been at the centre of horticultural training and have provided excellence and advancements in the field. In recent decades, botanic gardens have also become an active part of ex situ conservation activities by storing seeds of endangered wild plants, growing living collections for conservation purposes, or propagating plants for direct reintroduction measures. While this shift in focus has been necessary and very important, ex situ collections of wild plants have been criticised for being
genetically impoverished, potentially hybridised with congeners, or adapted to the artificial garden conditions and potentially having lost specific adaptations to their original wild habitat. In this review, we provide an overview of these potential threats to wild plants in ex situ living collections and outline examples of how ex situ cultivation can affect genetic diversity, trait expression and adaptive responses of the plants. We evaluate what these changes could mean for the conservation value of the collections, and discuss how they could be avoided by refining horticultural practices. 

Author Biographies

Andreas Ensslin, Botanical Garden of the University of Bern
Andreas Ensslin was previously a postdoctoral fellow at Botanic Garden Meise. He is currently a postdoc at the Botanical Garden of the University of Bern.
Sandrine Godefroid, Botanic Garden Meise, employed by the Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles.
Conservation Officer at Botanic Garden Meise, employed by the Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles.

References

ARAKI, H., COOPER, B. & BLOUIN, M.S. (2009). Carry-over effect of captive breeding reduces reproductive fitness of wild-born descendants in the wild. Biology Letters, 5(5): 621–624.

BAER, S.G., GIBSON, D.J., GUSTAFSON, D.J., BENSCOTER, A.M., REED, L.K., CAMPBELL, R.E., KLOPF, R.P., WILLAND, J.E. & WODIKA, B.R. (2013). No effect of seed source on multiple aspects of ecosystem functioning during ecological restoration: Cultivars compared to local ecotypes of dominant grasses. Evolutionary Applications, 7(2): 323–335.

BASEY, A.C., FANT, J.B. & KRAMER, A.T. (2015). Producing native plant materials for restoration: 10 rules to collect and maintain genetic diversity. Native Plants Journal, 16(1): 37–53.

BRÜTTING, C., HENSEN, I. & WESCHE, K. (2013). Ex situ cultivation affects genetic structure and diversity in arable plants. Plant Biology, 15(3): 505–513.

CARROLL, S.P., HENDRY, A.P., REZNICK, D.N. & FOX, C.W. (2007). Evolution on ecological time-scales. Functional Ecology, 21(3): 387–393.

DALRYMPLE, S.E., BANKS, E., STEWART, G.B. & PULLIN, A.S. (2012). A meta-analysis of threatened plant reintroductions from across the globe. In: MASCHINSKI, J. & HASKINS, K.E. (eds) Plant Reintroduction in a Changing Climate: Promises and Perils. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 31–50.

DONALDSON, J.S. (2009). Botanic gardens science for conservation and global change. Trends in Plant Science, 14(11): 608–613.

DYER, A.R., KNAPP, E.E. & RICE, K.J. (2016). Unintentional selection and genetic changes in native commercial seed production. Ecological Restoration, 34(1): 39–48.

ENGELMANN, F. (2002). Technologies and strategies for ex situ conservation. In: ENGELS, J.M.M., RAMANATHA RAO, V., BROWN, A.H.D. & JACKSON, M.T. (eds) Managing Plant Genetic Diversity. IPGRI, Rome, pp. 89–104.

ENSCONET (2009). ENSCONET Seed Collecting Manual for Wild Species. European Native Seed Conservation Network.

ENSSLIN, A., SANDNER, T.M. & MATTHIES, D. (2011). Consequences of ex situ cultivation of plants: Genetic diversity, fitness and adaptation of the monocarpic Cynoglossum officinale L. in botanic gardens. Biological Conservation, 144(1): 272–278.

ENSSLIN, A., TSCHÖPE, O., BURKART, M. & JOSHI, J. (2015). Fitness decline and adaptation to novel environments in ex situ plant collections: Current knowledge and future perspectives. Biological Conservation, 192: 394–401.

ENSSLIN, A., VAN DE VYVER, A., VANDERBORGHT, T. & GODEFROID, S. (2018). Ex situ cultivation entails high risk of dormancy loss on short-lived wild plant species. Journal of Applied Ecology, 55(3): 1145–1154.

FRACHON, N. (2013). Plant health protocols for the reintroduction of native plants. Sibbaldia, 11: 53–60.

FRANKHAM, R., BALLOU, J.D., RALLS, K., ELDRIDGE, M., DUDASH, M.R., FENSTER, C.B., LACY, R.C. & SUNNUCKS, P. (2017). Genetic Management of Endangered Plant and Animal Populations. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

FRANKHAM, R., BRADSHAW, C.J.A. & BROOK, B.W. (2014). Genetics in conservation management: Revised recommendations for the 50/500 rules, Red List criteria and population viability analyses. Biological Conservation, 170: 56–63.

FULLER, D.Q. & ALLABY, R. (2009). Seed dispersal and crop domestication: Shattering, germination and seasonality in evolution under cultivation. Annual Plant Reviews, 38: 238–295.

GODEFROID, S. & ENSSLIN, A. (2017). Herintroductie van plantensoorten: een toekomstgerichte instandhoudingsmaatregel. Natuur Focus, 16(1): 32–40.

GODEFROID, S., PIAZZA, C., ROSSI, G., BUORD, S., STEVENS, A.-D., AGURAIUJA, R., COWELL, C., WEEKLEY, C.W., VOGG, G., IRIONDO, J.M., JOHNSON, I., DIXON, B., GORDON, D., MAGNANON, S., VALENTIN, B., BJUREKE, K., KOOPMAN, R., VICENS, M. … & VANDERBORGHT, T. (2011). How successful are plant species reintroductions? Biological Conservation, 144(2): 672–682.

GRATZFELD, J. (2017). What is conservation horticulture? BG Journal, 14(2): 14–17.

GREENLEAF, S.S., WILLIAMS, N.M., WINFREE, R. & KREMEN, C. (2007). Bee foraging ranges and their relationship to body size. Oecologia, 153(3): 589–596.

GUERRANT, E.O., FIEDLER, P.L., HAVENS, K. & MAUNDER, M. (2004). Revised genetic sampling guidelines for conservation collections of rare and endangered plants. In: Ex Situ Plant Conservation: Supporting Species Survival in the Wild. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 419–441.

HAMILTON, N.R.S. & CHORLTON, K.H. (1996). Regeneration of accessions in seed collections: A decision guide. In: ENGELS, J. (ed.) Handbook for Genebanks. International Plant Genetic Resources Institute, Rome.

HAMMER, K. (1984). Das Domestikationssyndrom. Die Kulturpflanze, 32(1): 11–34.

HAVENS, K., GUERRANT, E.O., MAUNDER, M. & VITT, P. (2004). Guidelines for ex situ conservation collection management. Minimizing risks. In: GUERRANT, E.O., HAVENS, K. & MAUNDER, M. (eds) Ex Situ Plant Conservation: Supporting Species Survival in the Wild. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 454–473.

HEISER, C.B. (1988). Aspects of unconscious selection and the evolution of domesticated plants. Euphytica, 37(1): 77–81.

HERGET, M.E., HUFFORD, K.M., MUMMEY, D.L. & SHREADING, L.N. (2015). Consequences of seed origin and biological invasion for early establishment in restoration of a North American grass species. PLoS One, 10, e0119889.

HEYWOOD, V.H. (2011). The role of botanic gardens as resource and introduction centres in the face of global change. Biodiversity and Conservation, 20(2): 221–239.

HOBAN, S. & SCHLARBAUM, S. (2014). Optimal sampling of seeds from plant populations for ex-situ conservation of genetic biodiversity, considering realistic population structure. Biological Conservation, 177: 90–99.

HUSBAND, B.C. & CAMPBELL, L.G. (2004). Population responses to novel environments: Implications for ex situ plant conservation. In: GUERRANT, E.O., HAVENS, K. & MAUNDER, M. (eds) Ex Situ Plant Conservation: Supporting Species Survival in the Wild. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 231–285.

INFOFLORA (2018). Empfehlungen zur ex situ-Erhaltung und Ansiedlung gefährdeter Pflanzen. Available online: http://www.infoflora.ch/de/assets/content/documents/Ex-situ_Introduction_D_F_I/InfoFlora_Empfehlungen_Ansiedlung.pdf (accessed April 2018).

IUCN/SSC (2013). Guidelines for reintroductions and other conservation translocations. Available online: https://portals.iucn.org/library/sites/library/files/documents/2014-064.pdf (accessed April 2018).

IUCN/SSC (2014). Guidelines on the use of ex situ management for species conservation. Available online: https://portals.iucn.org/library/node/44952 (accessed April 2018).

KELLER, M., KOLLMANN, J. & EDWARDS, P.J. (2000). Genetic introgression from distant provenances reduces fitness in local weed populations. Journal of Applied Ecology, 37(4): 647–659.

KLOPF, R.P. & BAER, S.G. (2011). Root dynamics of cultivar and non-cultivar population sources of two dominant grasses during initial establishment of tallgrass prairie. Restoration Ecology, 19(1): 112–117.

KLUYVER, T.A., JONES, G., PUJOL, B., BENNETT, C., MOCKFORD, E.J., CHARLES, M., REES, M. & OSBORNE, C.P. (2017). Unconscious selection drove seed enlargement in vegetable crops. Evolution Letters, 1(2): 1–9.

KNAPP, E.E. & RICE, K.J. (1994). Starting from seed: Genetic issues in using native grasses for restoration. Restoration & Management Notes, 12(1): 40–45.

LAUTERBACH, D. (2013). Ex situ-Kulturen gefährdeter Wildpflanzen–Populationsgenetische Aspekte und Empfehlungen für Besammlung, Kultivierung und Wiederausbringung. Anliegen Natur, 35(2): 32–39.

LAUTERBACH, D., BURKART, M. & GEMEINHOLZER, B. (2012). Rapid genetic differentiation between ex situ and their in situ source populations: An example of the endangered Silene otites (Caryophyllaceae). Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 168(1): 64–75.

MAUNDER, M. (1994). Botanic gardens: Future challenges and responsibilities. Biodiversity and Conservation, 3(2): 97–103.

MAUNDER, M., HAVENS, K., GUERRANT, E.O. & FALK, D.A. (2004a). Ex situ methods: A vital but underused set of conservation resources. In: GUERRANT, E.O., HAVENS, K. & MAUNDER, M. (eds) Ex Situ Plant Conservation: Supporting Species Survival in the Wild. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 3–20.

MAUNDER, M., HUGHES, C., HAWKES, J.A. & CULHAM, A. (2004b). Hybridization in ex situ plant collections: Conservation concerns, liabilities and opportunities. In: GUERRANT, E.O., HAVENS, K. & MAUNDER, M. (eds) Ex Situ Plant Conservation: Supporting Species Survival in the Wild. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 325–364.

MEYER, R.S., DUVAL, A.E. & JENSEN, H.R. (2012). Patterns and processes in crop domestication: An historical review and quantitative analysis of 203 global food crops. New Phytologist, 196(1): 29–48.

MILLA, R., GARC, P. & MATESANZ, S. (2017). Looking at past domestication to secure ecosystem services of future croplands. Journal of Ecology, 105(4): 885–889.

MILLA, R., OSBORNE, C.P., TURCOTTE, M.M. & VIOLLE, C. (2015). Plant domestication through an ecological lens. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 30(8): 463–469.

MÜLLER, C.M., HUWE, B., WISSEMANN, V., JOSHI, J. & GEMEINHOLZER, B. (2017). Conservation genetic assessment of four plant species in a small replica of a steppe ecosystem >30 years after establishment. Biodiversity and Conservation, 26 (11): 2699–2716.

NAMOFF, S., HUSBY, C.E., FRANCISCO-ORTEGA, J., NOBLICK, L.R., LEWIS, C.E. & GRIFFITH, M.P. (2010). How well does a botanical garden collection of a rare palm capture the genetic variation in a wild population?. Biological Conservation, 143(5): 1110–1117.

NSRF (National Species Reintroduction Forum) (2018). The Scottish code for conservation translocations: Best practice guidelines for conservation translocations in Scotland. Available online: http://www.gwct.org.uk/media/406156/Scottish-Code-for-Conservation-Translocations.pdf (accessed April 2018).

PRASSE, R., KUNZMANN, D. & SCHRÖDER, R. (2010). Entwicklung und praktische Umsetzung naturschutzfachlicher Mindestanforderungen an einen Herkunftsnachweis für gebietseigenes Wildpflanzensaatgut krautiger Pflanzen Abschlussbericht. Deutsche Bundesstiftung Umwelt. Available online: https://www.dbu.de/OPAC/ab/DBUAbschlussbericht-AZ-23931.pdf (accessed April 2018).

RAE, D. (2011). Fit for purpose: The importance of quality standards in the cultivation and use of live plant collections for conservation. Biodiversity and Conservation, 20(2): 241–258.

RAUSCHKOLB, R. (2017). Does ex situ cultivation of rare plant species in botanical gardens lead to loss of adaptation to the wild? Unpublished Master’s thesis, University of Tübingen.

RUCINSKA, A. & PUCHALSKI, J. (2011). Comparative molecular studies on the genetic diversity of an ex situ garden collection and its source population of the critically endangered Polish endemic plant Cochlearia polonica E. Fröhlich. Biodiversity and Conservation, 20(2): 401–413.

SCBD (2010). Global Strategy for Plant Conservation. Updated Strategy 2011–2020. Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity. Available online: http://www.cbd.int/gspc/about.shtml (accessed December 2013).

SCHAAL, B.B. & LEVERICH, W.J. (2004). Population genetic issues in ex situ conservation. In: GUERRANT, E.O., HAVENS, K. & MAUNDER, M. (eds) Ex Situ Plant Conservation: Supporting Species Survival in the Wild. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 267–285.

SCHOEN, D.J. & BROWN, A.H.D. (2001). The conservation of wild plant species in seed banks. BioScience, 51(11): 960–966.

SCHOEN, D.J., DAVID, J.L. & BATAILLON, T.M. (1998). Deleterious mutation accumulation and the regeneration of genetic resources. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 95(1): 394–399.

SCHRÖDER, R. & PRASSE, R. (2013a). Cultivation and hybridization alter the germination behavior of native plants used in revegetation and restoration. Restoration Ecology, 21(6): 793–800.

SCHRÖDER, R. & PRASSE, R. (2013b). From nursery into nature: A study on performance of cultivated varieties of native plants used in re-vegetation, their wild relatives and evolving wild × cultivar hybrids. Ecological Engineering, 60: 428–437.

SCHRÖDER, R., GRAF, M.D., JOCHUM, J., RODE, G. & SCHEMMEL, J. (2013). Testing the effects of a regionalized seed production on the germination behavior of wild plant species. Ecological Restoration, 31(3): 295–301.

VITT, P. & HAVENS, K. (2004). Integrating quantitative genetics into ex situ conservation and restoration practices. In: GUERRANT, E.O., HAVENS, K. & MAUNDER, M. (eds) Ex Situ Plant Conservation: Supporting Species Survival in the Wild. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 286–304.

VOLIS, S. (2017). Conservation utility of botanic garden living collections: Setting a strategy and appropriate methodology. Plant Diversity, 39(6): 365–372.

VOLIS, S. & BLECHER, M. (2010). Quasi in situ: A bridge between ex situ and in situ conservation of plants. Biodiversity and Conservation, 19(9): 2441–2454.

WALKER, K.J., HODDER, K.H., BULLOCK, J.B. & PYWELL, R.F. (2004). A Review of the Potential Effects of Seed Sowing for Habitat Re-creation on the Conservation of Introspecific Biodiversity. Defra Contract BD1447. Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Monks Wood.

WALKER, E., MEIMBERG, H. & KOLLMANN, J. (2014). Mixed evidence for the cultivar vigour hypothesis: The case of calcareous grassland forbs in a matrix of Festuca rubra. Ecological Engineering, 71: 301–307.

WIKIPEDIA (2018). Available online: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horticulture (accessed April 2018).

WILLAND, J.E., BAER, S.G. & GIBSON, D.J. (2015). Propagule abundance and richness are equivalent or higher in communities restored with local ecotypes relative to cultivars of dominant species. Journal of Vegetation Science, 26(3): 421–430.

WILLI, Y., VAN BUSKIRK, J. & HOFFMANN, A.A. (2006). Limits to the adaptive potential of small populations. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics, 37: 433–458.

WILLIAMS, S.E. & HOFFMAN, E.A. (2009). Minimizing genetic adaptation in captive breeding programs: A review. Biological Conservation, 142(11): 2388–2400.

WITZENBERGER, K.A. & HOCHKIRCH, A. (2011). Ex situ conservation genetics: A review of molecular studies on the genetic consequences of captive breeding programmes for endangered animal species. Biodiversity and Conservation, 20(9): 1843–1861.

WYSE JACKSON, P.S. & SUTHERLAND, L.A. (2000). International Agenda for Botanic Gardens in Conservation. Botanic Gardens Conservation International, Richmond.

ZHANG, J.J., YE, Q.G., YAO, X.H. & HUANG, H.W. (2010). Spontaneous interspecific hybridization and patterns of pollen dispersal in ex situ populations of a tree species (Sinojackia xylocarpa) that is extinct in the wild. Conservation Biology, 24(1): 246–255.

ZOHARY, D. (2004). Unconscious selection and the evolution of domesticated plants. Economic Botany, 58(1): 5–10.

Published
2019-02-05
How to Cite
Ensslin, A., & Godefroid, S. (2019). How the Cultivation of Wild Plants in Botanic Gardens can Change their Genetic and Phenotypic Status and What This Means for their Conservation Value. Sibbaldia: The Journal of Botanic Garden Horticulture, (17), 51-70. https://doi.org/10.23823/Sibbaldia/2019.267
Section
Articles